View Issue Details

IDProjectCategoryView StatusLast Update
0005472DarkRadiantMap Editingpublic23.03.2021 12:47
Reporterelojalapeno Assigned To 
PrioritynormalSeveritynormalReproducibilityalways
Status acknowledgedResolutionopen 
Product Version2.10.0 
Summary0005472: Alternative grid increments like 1/10/100/250/500/1000
DescriptionSince I'm not mapping for Doom 3 alike, would it be possible to change sizes of grid? Instead of power of 2, i would like to have like 1/10/100/250/500/1000. Would it be possible to implement it?

greebo: Edited the title and the description, original description goes below. See discussion for details.
Would it be possible to implement centimeter grid scale? I'm using Dark Radiant primarly for UE4, and I would like a more snapping values for my assets. It's hard to snap modules with inches back in UE4. So scaling it by 2.54 would be beneficial to my needs. What do you think?
TagsNo tags attached.

Activities

greebo

greebo

04.01.2021 01:59

administrator   ~0013355

Last edited: 04.01.2021 02:00

View 2 revisions

Isn't the DarkRadiant grid just numbers without units? If you draw a flat patch and snap it from -60 from 60, there's nothing telling us that the width is 120 centimeters or 120 feet. What's the workflow from DR to UE4? Is there a model export involved, or why are the units not working in UE4?
orbweaver

orbweaver

16.01.2021 16:56

developer   ~0013460

I agree with Greebo's comment. As far as I know there is no assumption by DarkRadiant that grid units represent inches, so I'm not sure what we could change that would make any difference here. This seems more like an issue with the model export workflow, either in the exporter plugin or the configuration of the initial scene.
elojalapeno

elojalapeno

22.03.2021 16:27

reporter   ~0013800

I'm sorry for very late response.
Currently I'm on newest radiant and the scale seems 1:1, ie 100 unit object will export as 100cm, that's great.

However since I'm not mapping for Doom 3 alike, would it be possible to change sizes of grid? Instead of power of 2, i would like to have like 1/10/100/250/500/1000. Would it be possible to implement it?
greebo

greebo

23.03.2021 06:31

administrator   ~0013801

Something like this is possible, but I estimate this to be a quite some work, since the base-2 grid scale is pretty much burnt into the code. However, the Grid code is a module, so it should be technically possible to implement an alternative one working with a different scale instead of the current geometric, powers-of-two scale. Given the amount of work though, I'd say the chances of this getting done are rather slim, unless this turns out to be more than a rare use case.
elojalapeno

elojalapeno

23.03.2021 12:21

reporter   ~0013802

I would use it at all times. It would make designing easier, faster, now acetate and easier on eyes when building. Looking forward to it one day.
greebo

greebo

23.03.2021 12:45

administrator   ~0013803

Ok, I'll edit the request title, and leave this issue open for anyone to chime in.

Issue History

Date Modified Username Field Change
29.12.2020 22:22 elojalapeno New Issue
04.01.2021 01:59 greebo Note Added: 0013355
04.01.2021 01:59 greebo Status new => feedback
04.01.2021 02:00 greebo Note Edited: 0013355 View Revisions
16.01.2021 16:56 orbweaver Note Added: 0013460
22.03.2021 16:27 elojalapeno Note Added: 0013800
22.03.2021 16:27 elojalapeno Status feedback => new
23.03.2021 06:31 greebo Note Added: 0013801
23.03.2021 06:31 greebo Status new => acknowledged
23.03.2021 12:21 elojalapeno Note Added: 0013802
23.03.2021 12:45 greebo Note Added: 0013803
23.03.2021 12:47 greebo Summary Request to change grid from inches to centimeters (x2.54) => Alternative grid increments like 1/10/100/250/500/1000
23.03.2021 12:47 greebo Description Updated View Revisions