View Issue Details
|ID||Project||Category||View Status||Date Submitted||Last Update|
|0004247||The Dark Mod||Animation||public||05.11.2015 21:05||09.12.2022 03:33|
|Product Version||TDM 2.03|
|Target Version||TDM 2.11||Fixed in Version||TDM 2.11|
|Summary||0004247: Using the crouch key when climbing a ladder or a pipe|
|Description||When climbing in crouch mode and part way up press the crouch key|
The crouch icon changes and the player stands up and the light gem changes
However when in standing up mode and pressing crouch the crouch icon changes but the player doesn't crouch down and the light gem doesn't change to reflect the crouched position
I would have assumed that the crouch/standing action would move the players body relative to his feet and this happens when standing up but not when going back to crouch
-When I attach to the ladder crouched, I climb slowly and the lightgem is darker.
-If I then stand-up, I climb faster and the lightgem is brighter.
-Going back to crouch again only changes the crouch indicator, but climb speed and lightgem remains unaffected.
According to the code, the player is supposed to climb ladders standing up, which is pretty realistic. But what should happen when the player attaches to a ladder crouched? Automatically making him stand-up could make him visible to AI, so this is a no-go. Applying the crouched modifier while climbing leads to the observed inconsistency, though. So, what should we do? I suggest to remove the limitation that player must only climb standing up. It is not THAT unrealistic to imagine someone climbing a ladder crouched and it doesn't look and feel like a bug anymore.
"Automatically making him stand-up could make him visible to AI, so this is a no-go."
On the other side climbing a ladder crouched (however this is supposed to work) wouldn't really make you less visible. IIRC in Thi4f and probably also TDS the player stood up when climbing ladders and at least in Thi4f the lightgem got brighter doing so. I would have to check but at least it didn't bother me.
So you argument only holds if players would NOT expect to become more visible when climbing a ladder.
|05.11.2015 21:05||Oldjim||New Issue|
||Note Added: 0010204|
|01.01.2019 22:47||STiFU||Note Added: 0011211|
|01.01.2019 22:47||STiFU||Status||new => confirmed|
|05.01.2019 19:45||STiFU||Relationship added||related to 0001746|
|16.05.2022 20:31||Daft Mugi||Relationship added||related to 0005961|
|16.05.2022 20:37||Daft Mugi||Tag Attached: crouch|
|16.05.2022 20:53||Daft Mugi||Relationship added||related to 0005962|
|09.06.2022 08:44||Obsttorte||Note Added: 0014851|
|09.12.2022 03:31||nbohr1more||Status||confirmed => resolved|
|09.12.2022 03:31||nbohr1more||Resolution||open => fixed|
|09.12.2022 03:31||nbohr1more||Fixed in Version||=> TDM 2.11|
|09.12.2022 03:31||nbohr1more||Target Version||=> TDM 2.11|
|09.12.2022 03:33||nbohr1more||Assigned To||=> stgatilov|