View Issue Details

IDProjectCategoryView StatusLast Update
0004750DarkRadiantScriptingpublic01.08.2020 20:28
Reporteruser81Assigned Togreebo  
PrioritynormalSeveritynormalReproducibilityalways
Status resolvedResolutionfixed 
PlatformPC, Windows, x64OSWin 7/8OS VersionSp2/8.1
Product Version2.5.0 
Target Version2.6.0Fixed in Version2.6.0 
Summary0004750: Export Selected as .LWO Model: Exported models loose smooth shading after export.
DescriptionTake any round object (patch, FS & .LWO model) and use the above function. The exported model then losses all the smooth-shading, the edges of the tessellation become hard-edged (see attached screenshot.
TagsNo tags attached.

Relationships

related to 0004766 closedgreebo Make The Model Exporter Respect The "skin" Spawnarg On Export 
related to 0004767 closedgreebo Re-exporting .ase models screws up their normals 
related to 0005115 new Export patches: .lwo loses smooth shading 

Activities

user81

17.03.2018 20:02

 

Capture.JPG (65,328 bytes)   
Capture.JPG (65,328 bytes)   

user81

17.03.2018 20:03

 

Spooks

Spooks

01.04.2018 11:43

reporter   ~0010341

From my testing, it seems that this problem only occurs with the .lwo export option. Ase exports look fine and smooth.

user81

01.04.2018 12:55

  ~0010342

Changed title, thanks for spotting that Spooks.
greebo

greebo

27.04.2018 18:07

administrator   ~0010404

LWO2 surfaces are now exported with a smoothing angle set. This is only noticeable on surfaces where vertices are shared across polys, something which is no longer lost during export. So, when exporting one or more selected models to an LWO or ASE model, their topology is now preserved such that surfaces aren't split up into separate triangles.

I tested this re-exporting or scaling the models/kitchen/bottle02.lwo file, and the output turned out as smooth as the source model.

user81

27.04.2018 18:30

  ~0010407

Greebo you a little star, this will save me having to redoo a lot of work on my large city mission.

user81

27.04.2018 19:27

  ~0010408

Atm to put the smoothing back on a previously exported model I have to export .ASE, I assume the above fix in the next version of DR will work the same way..?
Spooks

Spooks

11.05.2018 09:53

reporter   ~0010462

This has not been fixed, far as I can see.

Even re-exporting bottle02.lwo, for control test purposes, made the bottle have hard edges. A screenshot of another test, with my custom model, here: http://forums.thedarkmod.com/topic/19412-darkradiant-260-pre-release-testing/?p=421460
VanishedOne

VanishedOne

06.12.2018 20:51

developer   ~0010841

The linked thread seems inconclusive; should this be reopened? At the moment simple patchwork can look very unsmoothed after export.
Dragofer

Dragofer

01.08.2020 20:28

developer   ~0012709

The problem has been partially solved, now the exporter problems are only when exporting patches as models, while existing models can be re-exported fine without losing smooth shading (assuming they were smooth to begin with). I've opened more specific tickets for this, of which one is linked to this ticket. So this ticket doesn't need to be reopened.

Issue History

Date Modified Username Field Change
17.03.2018 20:02 user81 New Issue
17.03.2018 20:02 user81 Status new => assigned
17.03.2018 20:02 user81 Assigned To => greebo
17.03.2018 20:02 user81 File Added: Capture.JPG
17.03.2018 20:03 user81 File Added: shadowhide_2018-03-17_19.56.29.jpg
01.04.2018 11:43 Spooks Note Added: 0010341
01.04.2018 12:55 user81 Summary Export Selected as Model: Exported models loose smooth shading after export => Export Selected as .LWO Model: Exported models loose smooth shading after export.
01.04.2018 12:55 user81 Note Added: 0010342
02.04.2018 11:08 user81 Relationship added related to 0004766
02.04.2018 11:08 user81 Relationship added related to 0004767
02.04.2018 16:17 greebo Assigned To greebo =>
02.04.2018 16:17 greebo Status assigned => acknowledged
25.04.2018 17:00 greebo Status acknowledged => confirmed
25.04.2018 17:00 greebo Target Version 2.6.0 =>
25.04.2018 17:00 greebo Product Version 2.6.0 => 2.5.0
25.04.2018 21:10 user81 Description Updated View Revisions
27.04.2018 18:02 greebo Assigned To => greebo
27.04.2018 18:02 greebo Status confirmed => assigned
27.04.2018 18:02 greebo Target Version => 2.6.0
27.04.2018 18:07 greebo Note Added: 0010404
27.04.2018 18:07 greebo Status assigned => resolved
27.04.2018 18:07 greebo Fixed in Version => 2.6.0
27.04.2018 18:07 greebo Resolution open => fixed
27.04.2018 18:30 user81 Note Added: 0010407
27.04.2018 19:27 user81 Note Added: 0010408
11.05.2018 09:53 Spooks Note Added: 0010462
06.12.2018 20:51 VanishedOne Note Added: 0010841
31.07.2020 20:09 VanishedOne Relationship added related to 0005115
01.08.2020 20:28 Dragofer Note Added: 0012709